First published on LinkedIn, November 2026
Two loaves sat on the boardroom table. Everyone could tell which was better except me.
It was years ago, in a large plant bakery. I’d just joined as Production Director, and my predecessor was still there for the handover. He’d spent a lifetime in the business, as had everyone else there.
We were considering a change of flour spec for our highest-volume product. Many thousands of loaves a day, and the change impacted product cost and quality, so it was a big deal. The two loaves had been left for us to compare.
We prodded them, sniffed them, tasted them. Held slices up to the light to compare the crumb structure. Talked over each other. The MD’s verdict was clear: the second loaf was better. Result.
I felt a real newbie because I couldn’t detect any material difference, so I kept quiet.
I sidled out to the test bakery to ask the technical team to explain what the new flour changed. They said they were about to bring the new test loaves to the boardroom and could show me them side by side.
What?
Both loaves we’d been looking at so far were from standard production.
The MD was a strong personality, and everyone followed his enthusiasm. No one paused to challenge. As the new guy round a table full of experience, I hadn’t been brave enough to say they looked the same to me.
I’ve seen the same thing many times since. Someone influential gives a view, the discussion gathers energy and urgency, and anyone with doubts has to interrupt to say so.
Yes, they should. Because if they don’t say what they think or ask their question, what’s the point in having them there?
But no, it’s not easy, and the senior person has to make it easier.
Now I’m the one with the most years at the table. When I catch myself pushing a view, I try to say something like, “Sorry, I’m getting ahead of myself. There has to be something I’m missing. What is it?”
Then I give people time to answer. Sometimes it’s as well I did.